There was a British comedy series that I cannot for the life of me remember the name of that always had a spot where they'd do a first person scene. I never saw it here, I only ever caught it when I was working in the UK. The best one they did was at a funeral where everyone was getting drunk and hitting on the widow.
You're right about Zemeckis. He made a film called Used Cars which wasn't half bad but didn't do all that well at the box office. I figure he very quickly found himself in the place Coppola and Scorcese found themselves in much further down their roads where they realized the day of the auteur was done and if they wanted to keep making movies they had better belly up to the same trough as everyone else and churn out popcorn pap for the masses. The closest Spielberg has ever gone to true drama was Schindler's List and he even managed to fuck that up. Maybe they should start pairing directors together, combining their strengths, although anything done by committee sucks big steamy turds. At the very least it would make for some great fractious behind the scenes stories.
Harrow Alley was written by Walter Newman who was, in his time, regarded as one of the best screenwriters - ever. He's uncredited on a lot of pictures because he was also an irrascible bastard who would get fumingly fed up with the studio bullshit and pull his name off projects despite being eligible under Writer's Guild rules for full credit. The Great Escape is the most outstanding example. He wrote Harrow Alley on spec and found that while it was highly regarded by all who read it, it was at the same time deemed to be completely unproduceable. Why? It's about the Black Plague. Not a good date flick or a feel good film of any sort. Yet it IS. The ending is superb and ties all the tangled threads together wonderfully. It passed through many hands over the years. Most notably George C. Scott owned it up to the time of his death and originally had hopes of starring in it and then towards the end was trying to get it made with Mel Gibson in the lead. I don't know if the rights remained with his estate after his passing, which might mean Campbell Scott could possibly control it now. It is a dark and bleak and nasty story simply because of the melieu. It's a difficult tale because most of the people you come to know and like in it die horribly and tragically ... it is the plague after all. I would like to think that in this day and age of films like Saw and Hostel ... and all the other crap the Americans are trying so desperately to scare themselves with, either in an unwitting exhibition of their own tortured (pun intended) zeitgeist or a desperate attempt to distract themselves from an oppressive reality that is far more terrible than any of their fearful imaginings (just as they did with the horror and SF films of the McCarthy era) ... that such a story could indeed find an audience. Now, actually, would be a good time for it. We need a compelling tale of life's continuance in the face of unrelenting suffering and death.
Thursday
Best Movies Never Made
This link was sent to me by Rob Mills (millsworks.net).
http://www.listology.com/content_show.cfm/content_id.13832
Best Movies Never Made by lukeprog
1. Stanley Kubrick's 'Napoleon' - No explanation necessary. Link
2. Orson Welles' 'Heart of Darkness' - Also no explanation necessary. Link
3. James Cameron's 'Avatar' - I just LOVE the idea of doing an epic alien love/war story entirely set on another planet. One day when I'm 'in,' I'm going to write a similar script that can be made on a smaller budget. Link
4. Alfred Hitchcock's 'Kaleidoscope' - Concerning a serial rapist and killer, this could have been Hitch's darkest movie. He also wanted to shoot the whole movie from the killer's POV. Great stuff, but of course it was too ugly and dark for its time, and studio brass turned it down. Link
5. 'Don Quixote' - A literary classic that is the curse of every director that tries to bring it to life. Orson Welles tried it, and failed. Gilliam tried it decades later - the resulting failure produced the documentary 'Lost in La Mancha'. It's a movie that defies its directors to be made. Link
6. Terry Gilliam's... Everything - Gilliam is an exciting and imaginative filmmaker. He's also been involved in more projects that failed to get the final green light than anyone I can think of. See the long list of really great projects that never quite made it: Link.
7. Carl Dreyer's 'Jesus' - I still hold that a decent & reasonably accurate account of one of the best stories ever told (whether you believe it's true or not) has not been filmed. But if anyone could've made an excellent and challenging spiritual drama, it would've been Dreyer. Link.
8. David Lean's 'Nostromo' - He was developing Joseph Conrad's epic Nostromo when he died in 1991. Could've been another Bridge on the River Kwai or Doctor Zhivago. Link.
9. Andrzej Munk's 'Passenger' - Andrzej Munk died during filming from a car crash. What survives of Munk's work is brilliant, what was 'filled in' to copmlete the film by Witold Lesiewicz is, well, not Munk's movie. Link
10. Lem Dobbs' 'Edward Ford' - A really, really great script. I can understand while certain other projects on this list didn't make it, but this one dumfounds me. Certainly this would have at least as big an audience as his other projects, like Kafka, Dark City, and The Limey? There's hope for this one yet. I have a copy of the script if you want to read it. Link
11. 'The Catcher in the Rye' - Several directors have been interested in developing an adaptation of this classic novel, but the author isn't too keen on the idea. Link
12. David Lynch's 'Ronny Rocket' - David Lynch's script for a followup to Eraserhead has floated around Hollywood for 20 years and never quite gotten the green light. Link
13. Ray Bradbury's 'The Dreamers' - A terrific novel and a terrific script for this promising supernatural thriller couldn't attract any Hollywood talent in 1958. Link
14. 'I am Legend' - Plenty of big-name actors have jumped on board with this kickass-sounding project, but the budget has always been the problem that sunk it. There's still hope for this one. Link
15. Disney's 'A Princess of Mars' - This would have been the first animated feature, before Snow White, had it not been scrapped. And back then, Disney was making really good movies. Link
16. Benjamin Christensen's 'The Saints and The Spirits' - Christensen intended, and began to shoot a trilogy of spiritual investigation films that began with the amazing Haxan, but the two followups were never realized due to a financial crisis.
17. Sergei Eisenstein's 'Que Viva Mexico' - The maker of the superb The Battleship Potemkin wanted to make a social history of Mexico, but couldn't get funding. Some footage was actually shot, and revealed the film's innovative approach, but his full vision was never realized. Link
18. James Cameron's 'Spider-Man' - Despite True Lies, I have faith that James Cameron's Spider-Man would have been far superior to what Raimi has given us. Link
19. 'Manhattan Ghost Story' - A really cool novel that was ripped off by the wildly popular The Sixth Sense. But, now, The Others was made, so why can't this one succeed, too? Link
20. Honorable Mention: Orson Welles' Batman - Orson Welles' vision of Batman was a dark, serious psycho-drama. Had it made it past the silly little casting disagreement that sunk it, it might have single-handedly brought a public popularity and respect for comics that has never existed, at a time when comic books were in their infancy. Link - This is a hoax!
Maybe we can add Megalopolis to this list. Rob would have added Walter Newman's 'Harrow Alley'.
As far as I know James Cameron is working on Avatar right now and will be out in 3D in 2009.
http://www.listology.com/content_show.cfm/content_id.13832
Best Movies Never Made by lukeprog
1. Stanley Kubrick's 'Napoleon' - No explanation necessary. Link
2. Orson Welles' 'Heart of Darkness' - Also no explanation necessary. Link
3. James Cameron's 'Avatar' - I just LOVE the idea of doing an epic alien love/war story entirely set on another planet. One day when I'm 'in,' I'm going to write a similar script that can be made on a smaller budget. Link
4. Alfred Hitchcock's 'Kaleidoscope' - Concerning a serial rapist and killer, this could have been Hitch's darkest movie. He also wanted to shoot the whole movie from the killer's POV. Great stuff, but of course it was too ugly and dark for its time, and studio brass turned it down. Link
5. 'Don Quixote' - A literary classic that is the curse of every director that tries to bring it to life. Orson Welles tried it, and failed. Gilliam tried it decades later - the resulting failure produced the documentary 'Lost in La Mancha'. It's a movie that defies its directors to be made. Link
6. Terry Gilliam's... Everything - Gilliam is an exciting and imaginative filmmaker. He's also been involved in more projects that failed to get the final green light than anyone I can think of. See the long list of really great projects that never quite made it: Link.
7. Carl Dreyer's 'Jesus' - I still hold that a decent & reasonably accurate account of one of the best stories ever told (whether you believe it's true or not) has not been filmed. But if anyone could've made an excellent and challenging spiritual drama, it would've been Dreyer. Link.
8. David Lean's 'Nostromo' - He was developing Joseph Conrad's epic Nostromo when he died in 1991. Could've been another Bridge on the River Kwai or Doctor Zhivago. Link.
9. Andrzej Munk's 'Passenger' - Andrzej Munk died during filming from a car crash. What survives of Munk's work is brilliant, what was 'filled in' to copmlete the film by Witold Lesiewicz is, well, not Munk's movie. Link
10. Lem Dobbs' 'Edward Ford' - A really, really great script. I can understand while certain other projects on this list didn't make it, but this one dumfounds me. Certainly this would have at least as big an audience as his other projects, like Kafka, Dark City, and The Limey? There's hope for this one yet. I have a copy of the script if you want to read it. Link
11. 'The Catcher in the Rye' - Several directors have been interested in developing an adaptation of this classic novel, but the author isn't too keen on the idea. Link
12. David Lynch's 'Ronny Rocket' - David Lynch's script for a followup to Eraserhead has floated around Hollywood for 20 years and never quite gotten the green light. Link
13. Ray Bradbury's 'The Dreamers' - A terrific novel and a terrific script for this promising supernatural thriller couldn't attract any Hollywood talent in 1958. Link
14. 'I am Legend' - Plenty of big-name actors have jumped on board with this kickass-sounding project, but the budget has always been the problem that sunk it. There's still hope for this one. Link
15. Disney's 'A Princess of Mars' - This would have been the first animated feature, before Snow White, had it not been scrapped. And back then, Disney was making really good movies. Link
16. Benjamin Christensen's 'The Saints and The Spirits' - Christensen intended, and began to shoot a trilogy of spiritual investigation films that began with the amazing Haxan, but the two followups were never realized due to a financial crisis.
17. Sergei Eisenstein's 'Que Viva Mexico' - The maker of the superb The Battleship Potemkin wanted to make a social history of Mexico, but couldn't get funding. Some footage was actually shot, and revealed the film's innovative approach, but his full vision was never realized. Link
18. James Cameron's 'Spider-Man' - Despite True Lies, I have faith that James Cameron's Spider-Man would have been far superior to what Raimi has given us. Link
19. 'Manhattan Ghost Story' - A really cool novel that was ripped off by the wildly popular The Sixth Sense. But, now, The Others was made, so why can't this one succeed, too? Link
20. Honorable Mention: Orson Welles' Batman - Orson Welles' vision of Batman was a dark, serious psycho-drama. Had it made it past the silly little casting disagreement that sunk it, it might have single-handedly brought a public popularity and respect for comics that has never existed, at a time when comic books were in their infancy. Link - This is a hoax!
Maybe we can add Megalopolis to this list. Rob would have added Walter Newman's 'Harrow Alley'.
As far as I know James Cameron is working on Avatar right now and will be out in 3D in 2009.
Friday
Thursday
I'm with Rob
I was watching youtube today and thought how wonderful these little bits of media have survived.
A public repository of culture/humour/film/video/television is healthy.
Does the McDlt still exist? I find myself with a little craving...
A public repository of culture/humour/film/video/television is healthy.
Does the McDlt still exist? I find myself with a little craving...
Wednesday
Spielberg Part 2 - Saving Private Ryan

There have been a couple of instances where emotional manipulation has worked against Steven Spielberg. In particular, the case against 'Saving Private Ryan', Spielbergs visceral World War II picture. It's a pretty good film but has a few lapses in story logic, the worst one comes after you've seen the film and realize the manipulation that has gone on. It's dishonest and blatantly manipulative.
Take these images. In terms of reading the film and film grammar, the combination of these images tell me this: Old guy goes to war cemetary and is clearly broken up, remembering the horrors of his past. Cut to flash back, Omaha Beach, we set the scene - an attack from the water. Close up on shaking hands drawing the canteen to the lips and come down to a close up of Tom Hanks. The close up matches very close to the last image of the old man, so we assume that he is this character.
Now all of this is fine in the moment and for most of the picture until Tom Hanks is killed in action and we find out our old guy is Private Ryan. All of this is working on an emotional level but suddenly my brain goes - hey! Ryan was never at Omaha... Why did he go to Omaha? Maybe to see his brothers graves? I suppose that could be it. It brings me back to the beginning of the film and I start to realize the manipulation that has gone on to dupe me. It's a nice idea to start the film but ultimately reveals the wizard behind the curtain (Mr. Spielberg) and weakens the film.
Sometimes logic does need to trump emotion.
William Goldman wrote about 'Saving Private Ryan' in his book 'Which Lie Did I Tell': "Saving Private Ryan, with its justly famous twenty-four minute early battle sequence, its fine Homer-like Odyssey hour where Ryan is sought, becomes, once he is found, a disgrace. False in every conceivable way possible, including giving the lie to its great twenty-four minutes. That sequence told us war is hell, too. The last hour tells us that war can be a neat learning experience for little Matt Damon.
In other words, Hollywood horseshit."
Goldman seems to take the side of Mordecai Richlers issues with 'Schindler's List'. Goldman also has a big problem with another key logic issue (in a seperate essay). It has to do with Ryan's not wanting to leave when they find him. What human being wouldn't take the get out of jail free card? Especially when men have risked their lives for you, your brothers are all dead and your poor mother is at home with her soul crushed. The logic problem would have been easy to address and the film could have gone on the same way. Ryan agrees to go, they head out and spot the incoming German army who is blocking their avenue for retreat. They go back and tell the boys and fight it out.
The other question Goldman is asking is, what kind of War picture would you make? He uses Ingmar Bergman's 'Shame' as his personal benchmark. Coppola made 'Apocalypse Now', Terrence Malick made 'The Thin Red Line', Wolfgang Peterson made 'Das Boot'. These are very different kinds of War pictures. 'Saving Private Ryan' seems to be somewhere between the old time war pictures that showed men of valour and quiet heroes and the new kind of films where the gloves come off and the amp is turned up to eleven. Regardless, I don't hate the last hour of 'Saving Private Ryan' like Goldman as it is an interesting film to reflect on.
Tuesday
Steven Spielberg

I was watching Jaws last night and got to thinking about some of the things that have made Spielberg so successful. I am a firm believer that film is an emotional medium. It works its best magic when it is trying to make you feel something. This isn't to say that the collision of images doesn't create ideas and tickle the cerebral, however first and foremost it makes you feel something - anger, laughter, sadness, terror, melancholy, excitement, fear etc. There are few filmmakers that have a better knack for this than Steven Spielberg.
Critics accuse him of being sentimental and manipulative and I think there is something to be said for that. His dramas are most often in the realm of fantasy. He isn't Sidney Lumet or Igmar Bergman whose films are gentle, honest and made in the style of realism. And it certainly isn't the verite style of Vittorio De Sica and 'The Bicycle Thief'. Moredcai Richler once wrote an article called 'Why I Hated Schindler's List'. In the article he calls Spielberg a comic book maker and states that he lacked the dramatic depth needed for such delicate material. A rather harsh criticism but again, not without merit. His films often feature archetypes who are either good or evil. The brilliant exceptions that come to mind are John Malkovich's character in 'Empire of the Sun' (one of my favourite Spielberg films) and Ralph Fienne's character in 'Schindler's List'. Who knows how much this had to do with writing, directing or performing but rarely does a character in a Spielberg film have such depths. Does this make him a bad filmmaker? Hardly.

Spielberg works on a gut level and is a master manipulator when it comes to sound, light, composition and performance. His focus is razor sharp and he knows exactly how to pull at the audiences heart strings. These images I've pulled from E.T. are a great example of how well crafted and how confident he is at telling his stories. There are all sorts of logic issues in this sequence. First of all, what is the source of all these lights? Why do the 'bad' guys walk over a hill pushing the plastic tent? Why don't they have a truck and how long have they been pushing that thing? Why are they in space suits?
All of these questions of logic can pull the audience right out of the story but Spielberg has such terrific instincts for this material. He is totally fearless and pulls it off. Every piece that I described above isn't meant for your brain, it's meant for your gut. And this is where film has its power, the brain is overpowered by emotion (manipulated or truthful).
E.T. is a great film. Yes it's manipulative, yes it's sappy, and yes it works. Spielberg juggles the feelings of dread, joy and melancholy and plays the heart strings like a world class violinist. It's also optimistic, unlike his rendition of 'War of the Worlds'. Like 'Close Encounters', E.T. looks up at the sky with wonder, amazement and hope that not everything in the universe is hell bent on murder.
**Notice the terrific compositions, particularly the Wellesian angle of the towering man in the space suit. This low angle shot is all about the feeling of intimidation and fear. Hitchock was a master at these kinds of compositions as well. Images tell stories and just as important, they make us feel.
The Wind Chill Factor
In David Mamets 'Three Uses of the Knife: On the Nature and Purpose of Drama' Mamet puts forward the notion that drama is an inherent part of the human condition. It is what he calls 'the wind chill factor'. Even though the temperature in winter might only be
-10 degrees we dramatize it with the sinister wind chill factor creating an unbelievable -25 degree day. It is our nature, Mamet contests, to crave drama even where there is none. Yesterday in Toronto the temperature hit 34 degrees celcius but it wasn't dramatic enough so the weather was reported as 44 degrees with the 'humidex'. I guess we need the counterpart to the wind chill. It made me laugh - we are a melodramatic lot.
There are some who defy this intrinsic nature. You know the one - he corners you at a party and has stories without purpose or point - anecdotes without anecdotes.
-10 degrees we dramatize it with the sinister wind chill factor creating an unbelievable -25 degree day. It is our nature, Mamet contests, to crave drama even where there is none. Yesterday in Toronto the temperature hit 34 degrees celcius but it wasn't dramatic enough so the weather was reported as 44 degrees with the 'humidex'. I guess we need the counterpart to the wind chill. It made me laugh - we are a melodramatic lot.
There are some who defy this intrinsic nature. You know the one - he corners you at a party and has stories without purpose or point - anecdotes without anecdotes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)